I was too dumb to notice
That there's somethin' about you
What am I supposed to do
I sure wish I knew

All the butterflies I felt inside never really mattered
Wishful thoughts and sudden smiles ended being shattered
What are we supposed to be; I'm hopelessly addicted to you
But you never felt the same

Time may pass us by
But you'll stay stuck on my mind
And that moment we stared that night
I thought it was right
But maybe I was wrong all along

I held onto something that never really mattered
Stuck on that starting line
I'm still silently, quietly
Hoping you'll end up with me

I was too dumb to notice
There was somethin' about you
How are you supposed to see things
If only you knew

All the times we were together, I never really mattered
All you see is what you want; my heart is being shattered
What are we supposed to be; I'm helplessly addicted to you
But you never felt the same

Time may pass us by
But you'll stay stuck on my mind
And that moment we stared that night
I thought it was right
But maybe I was wrong all along

I held onto something that never really mattered
Stuck on that starting line
I'm still silently, quietly
Hoping you end up with me

Time may pass us by
But you'll stay stuck on my mind
And that moment we stared that night
I thought it was right, oh

Time may pass us by
But you'll stay stuck on my mind
And that moment we stared that night
I thought it was right
But maybe I was wrong all along

I held onto something that never really mattered
Stuck on that starting line
I'm still silently, quietly
Hoping you end up with me

I was too dumb to notice
That there's somethin' about you
What am I supposed to do if
I'm still stuck on you